Home Uman Q&A (0002)

Q&A (0002)

by Ozer Bergman
image_print

Question:

I keep getting opinions from some Orthodox Jews that weight training
for a Jew is considered goyish, and that it is stupid for Jews to train in
this way. I know that ancient Greeks trained this way at times and their
ways were certainly not ours. However in the context of today, is it improper
for a Jew to go to a gym and train with weights?

Answer:

Shalom!

Bodybuilding is certainly not your typical Jewish activity. The Orthodox Jewish knee-jerk reaction to bodybuilding is, “You’re not learning Torah. You’re not making money. It’s not practical. Our grandparents didn’t do it. It’s not part of our tradition.” Stereotypically, non-Jews, and we ourselves, think of Jews as brainy, not brawny. As the joke goes, by the time a Jewish boy is 14 he realizes that he is more likely to own a professional sports team rather than play for one! 🙂

Interestingly, Rebbe Nachman zal talks about bodybuilding in his story The Master of Prayer (in his work Sippurei Maasios/Rabbi Nachman’s Stories). Even though he depicts the negative side, of being overly involved and improperly motivated, the implication is that there is a positive side to taking care of the body.

Like any activity/hobby one might choose, e.g., stamp-collecting, one has to weigh if that’s the best use of his time and talents. There’s no reason why bodybuilding might not be the answer for an individual.

There is a story from the Baal Shem Tov. It may be apropos.

One of his chassidim once asked him about how he (the chassid) might learn to “eat in holiness.” The Baal Shem Tov told him to go to a certain village and spend Shabbos with the blacksmith. The chassid assumed that the blacksmith was one of the 36 hidden-tzadikim and anticipated learning Kabbalistic secrets of eating.

What he got instead was a mountain of a man who ate super-jumbo-sized portions and quantities of each course at each meal. There was zero Torah-talk at the Shabbos table. The blacksmith was too busy eating.

After Shabbos, the chassid thanked his host and mentioned that he had one question. “No disrespect intended, but why do you eat so much?!” The blacksmith answered, “My father was a skinny, nearly emaciated, person. Once he and I were walking and goyim attacked us. I was able to run away As I watched from my hiding place, I saw them set him on fire. Since he was so skinny he burnt only for a very short time and they made fun of Jews for being such runts that they don’t even make a decent fire.

“I decided then and there that I would show them. If they ever capture me, they’ll see how a Jew can burn!”

Hope this helped.

מאמרים קשורים

5 comments

Avatar
Deb November 5, 2010 - 6:24 pm

Since Osteoporosis runs in many lines of Eastern European Jews…then body Building, especially for women is essential.
If Jew believe that doing natural activities to heal your body is warranted…then body building would be the logical and smart course of action. If you aren’t healthy you can’t sit and study Talmud.
Study is food for the soul and mind…but you can’t approach full and total body health without a strong physical body.

My advise…..hit the gym…AND hit the books

Reply
Avatar
chaim November 8, 2010 - 3:35 am

there is a diffrence between bodybuilding and excersise bodybuilding is for looking muscular but excercise is healthy . so when you ask about wheight training I would say YES it’s goyish.

Reply
Ozer Bergman
Ozer Bergman November 9, 2010 - 12:54 pm

@Deb
Deb — if I’m not mistaken, the author of Chovot Levavot talks about the importance and need for exercise. Riding a bike, walking, maybe even jumping rope could be alternatives for those who can’t make it to a gym.

Reply
Ozer Bergman
Ozer Bergman November 9, 2010 - 12:58 pm

@chaim
Chaim, I don’t know what “weight training” is and why it doesn’t qualify as “exercise,” but I agree that if it’s just for “the sake of appearances” that it isn’t Jewish! (Although I think if we could ask Yaakov Avinu, he would tell us that sometimes it may pay to look like Esav! 🙂

Reply
Avatar
Maryjo December 6, 2018 - 5:56 pm

Admiring the time and effort you put into
your site and in depth information you provide. It’s awesome to
come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same old rehashed material.
Wonderful read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m including your RSS feeds
to my Google account.

Reply

Leave a Comment